Impressions from the anti-Trump rally, Melbourne February 3, 2017

By Larry Stillman. Hello all, I ran home like crazy to try to put in a report about the anti-Trump demo for those who are observant though as far as I can see, the sun is well and truly shining. Yes, there was a 1/2 hearted from Palestine to Mexico slogan attempt by the young ‘chair’ of the protest that annoyed me a bit, but there were as far as I can tell, no anti-Israel signs or posters, at least at the state library. I did not stay for the March down Bourke Street (why they felt the need to hold up trams etc. I don’t know, but this is masorti). Only one speaker made strong allusion to Israeli/Palestine as a parallel case of exclusion, and frankly, he said nothing that the ‘true’ Israeli left or Haaretz would not say. Richard di Natale spoke first (or was it second?), and nothing he said would have been objected to by anyone who opposes Trump. And thank you to Sheikh Mohamed Mohideen, of the Islamic Council for such perceptive and kind words about the important role of the Jewish community in the US –unity being shown- despite differences. I hope this message got through to more than a few people in attendance.Image may contain: 2 people, tree, crowd and outdoor Alexjo Sandra Nissen spoke and was great. The politics of the very factional left organisers may not have been everyone’s cup of tea, but I think it is fair to say that Alex was out there, loud, and proud, as an authentic Australian-Israeli activist (yes, not a Zionist, but a believer in bi-nationalism) who does not accept the current mainstream and especially Netanyahu narrative that supports, borders, walls, and discrimination. It took some effort to get the organisers to be inclusive. I think they learned a lesson, and she got a lot of applause. Watch the recording here. And a reflection: decades ago, a lot more protests, particularly on Vietnam War issues, were coordinated by a number of church, union, and other organisations. Such people and structures knew each other very well and used to working through differences and the order and focus of events (maybe students were more anarchic, I think so). And, the division of labour was well, highly gendered. I think most of the key people were men, and women were at home with the kids, or did the typing etc. It’s not like that any more. Of course there were exceptions, like Save our Sons.
One Nation's cancellation and a letter by Robin Rothfield<< >>The tradition of Palm Sunday rallies

About the author : AJDS

Has one comment to “Impressions from the anti-Trump rally, Melbourne February 3, 2017”

You can leave a reply or Trackback this post.
  1. Ruben - February 7, 2017 Reply

    I think it would be cool to talk about why we where there at the Anti-Trump rally, why it was important and why we need more of it. Not just an article based on the presumption that there must be something wrong to be pointed at, when lo and behold, there wasn’t really. Its uninspiring. Comments like ‘the true Israeli left’ and ‘the factional left’ are ironically factional.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.